Drought Brings Soul Searching to California Winemaking
New York Times, August 20, 2015
By Eric Asimov
St. HELENA, Calif. — At the rustic Smith-Madrone Vineyards high up on Spring Mountain, nobody has been thinking about the drought, which has absorbed so much of the conversation about California this year. Instead, concerns have been about the unnaturally warm stretch in January and February, which set the growing season in motion early. Then came a cold snap in May, which caused many growers to lose 40 to 50 percent of their crop. Then, a cooler-than-expected July, and, for much of Napa Valley, an early harvest in August.
“It’s been a normally bizarre year,” said Stuart Smith, who, with his brother, Charles, has seen a lot of weather extremes in their 44 years growing grapes and making wine at Smith-Madrone. Now he’s worried mostly about forest fires.
The drought may have turned all of California into a pitiless desert in the popular imagination, but a week in July spent visiting fine-wine regions all around the state painted a more nuanced picture. Across the state…the drought has caused soul-searching in the wine industry, even at places like Smith-Madrone, as wineries rethink how they use water and the way they do business. And everywhere, the fervent hope is that El Niño, the periodic ocean weather system, will bring rains this winter to renew Western water supplies.
While agriculture has generally been portrayed as California’s thirstiest industry, absorbing a high percentage of scarce resources, grape vines are not among the prime offenders. They are tenacious survivors, genetically programmed to thrive where other plants cannot.
At Smith-Madrone, Stuart Smith has become convinced that dry-farming is the way to go, not just because he thinks it results in better wine but because water in California has always been a moral issue. He said he’s seen far too many vineyards irrigated to achieve a garden-like beauty, to the detriment of both wine and water supplies. “From a wine-quality and a responsible-citizen position, we should all use less water,” he said. “Wine growers can make better wines and be better ecological neighbors if they thought about vineyards differently.”